If you enjoy pumpkin flavored everything year-round, then there’s a humble little bakery you need to know about: Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio. This beloved spot features some of the state’s best donuts, cookies, cakes and pies. Family owned and operated for more than 60 years, it’s a true Ohio treasure. All of the baked goods here are amazing—but the pumpkin donuts are practically legendary. And all it takes is one visit to see why. Check it out:

Tucked away in the small town of Circleville, you’ll find one of the best bakeshop in all of Ohio – and quite possibly America.

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook You’ll find it at 127 W Main St., Circleville, OH, 43113.

Since 1950, the Lindsey family has been serving up always fresh, never frozen baked goods. Everything here is delicious.

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook With a wide variety of baked goods, (all of which are completely made from scratch,) it can be difficult to choose.

You can’t leave Lindsey’s Bakery without some pumpkin donuts, which are (thankfully) made year-round…

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook …but be aware that if you come for pumpkin donuts during the Circleville Pumpkin Show, you will wait in a long, out-the-door line that weaves through the sidewalk. (It’s totally worth it though!)

During the Circleville Pumpkin Show season in October, the bakery also prepares and displays a massive pumpkin pie.

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook In fact, Lindsey’s Bakery has held the record for the world’s largest pumpkin pie for more than 40 years. In 2005, the bakery made a pie that measured 18-ft., taking back the world record yet again.

For decades, thousands of families have flocked to Lindsey’s Bakery during the town’s festival to see the massive pie and purchase some pumpkin donuts.

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook More than 400,00 people flock to the small town of Circleville each year to attend the Pumpkin Show. It’s a must-visit fall festival in Ohio!

Another delicious, simple treat the bakery makes year-round are thumbprint cookies, which you can get in a variety of colors.

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook They’re perfect for any holiday, game day, or any other special occasion you might be celebrating.

Lindsey’s Bakery is located at 127 W Main St., Circleville, OH, 43113. Have you ever been here before? If so, what are your favorite items to take home? Let us know!

Lindsey’s Bakery/Facebook

You’ll find it at 127 W Main St., Circleville, OH, 43113.

With a wide variety of baked goods, (all of which are completely made from scratch,) it can be difficult to choose.

…but be aware that if you come for pumpkin donuts during the Circleville Pumpkin Show, you will wait in a long, out-the-door line that weaves through the sidewalk. (It’s totally worth it though!)

In fact, Lindsey’s Bakery has held the record for the world’s largest pumpkin pie for more than 40 years. In 2005, the bakery made a pie that measured 18-ft., taking back the world record yet again.

More than 400,00 people flock to the small town of Circleville each year to attend the Pumpkin Show. It’s a must-visit fall festival in Ohio!

They’re perfect for any holiday, game day, or any other special occasion you might be celebrating.

For more delicious bakery destinations, check out our previous article: There’s A Bakery On This Beautiful Farm In Ohio And You Have To Visit.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: Lindsey’s Bakery, 127 W Main St, Circleville, OH 43113, USA

The OIYS Visitor Center

Lindsey’s Bakery Circleville Ohio August 19, 2022 Sarah M. Where else can I find pumpkin donuts in Ohio? While Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, is hailed as the place for pumpkin donuts in the Buckeye State, there’s a bakery in Butler County that certainly holds its own in the pumpkin spice arena. Holtman’s, a family-owned bakery with a few locations in Cincinnati, has a bakery in Butler County that’s part of the acclaimed and eponymous Butler County Donut Trail. Holtman’s might be best-known for its off-the-wall flavors combinations, but each fall, this bakery really outdoes itself in the seasonal flavor department. From the pumpkin spice latte donut and pumpkin brulee donut to the caramel apple donut, you’d be hard-pressed to find more seasonal donut flair in Ohio than Holtman’s! What orchards serve apple cider donuts in Ohio? Ahh, the apple cider donut, another seasonal treat that’s not to be missed! There are some amazing apple cider mills and orchards in Ohio; and, as a result, a very robust list of places to find apple cider donuts in Ohio! Some of our go-to spots for ah-mazing apple cider donuts in Ohio include Haus Orchard and Cider Mill, MacQueen’s Apple Barn and Cider Mill, Beckwith Orchards, Hirsch Fruit Farm, Laurelville Fruit Farm, and Lynd’s Fruit Farm. Oh, and guess what? Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, serves up incredible apple cider donuts, too!

The OIYS Visitor Center

Lindsey’s Bakery Circleville Ohio

August 19, 2022

Sarah M.

Where else can I find pumpkin donuts in Ohio? While Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, is hailed as the place for pumpkin donuts in the Buckeye State, there’s a bakery in Butler County that certainly holds its own in the pumpkin spice arena. Holtman’s, a family-owned bakery with a few locations in Cincinnati, has a bakery in Butler County that’s part of the acclaimed and eponymous Butler County Donut Trail. Holtman’s might be best-known for its off-the-wall flavors combinations, but each fall, this bakery really outdoes itself in the seasonal flavor department. From the pumpkin spice latte donut and pumpkin brulee donut to the caramel apple donut, you’d be hard-pressed to find more seasonal donut flair in Ohio than Holtman’s! What orchards serve apple cider donuts in Ohio? Ahh, the apple cider donut, another seasonal treat that’s not to be missed! There are some amazing apple cider mills and orchards in Ohio; and, as a result, a very robust list of places to find apple cider donuts in Ohio! Some of our go-to spots for ah-mazing apple cider donuts in Ohio include Haus Orchard and Cider Mill, MacQueen’s Apple Barn and Cider Mill, Beckwith Orchards, Hirsch Fruit Farm, Laurelville Fruit Farm, and Lynd’s Fruit Farm. Oh, and guess what? Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, serves up incredible apple cider donuts, too!

The OIYS Visitor Center

The OIYS Visitor Center

While Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, is hailed as the place for pumpkin donuts in the Buckeye State, there’s a bakery in Butler County that certainly holds its own in the pumpkin spice arena. Holtman’s, a family-owned bakery with a few locations in Cincinnati, has a bakery in Butler County that’s part of the acclaimed and eponymous Butler County Donut Trail. Holtman’s might be best-known for its off-the-wall flavors combinations, but each fall, this bakery really outdoes itself in the seasonal flavor department. From the pumpkin spice latte donut and pumpkin brulee donut to the caramel apple donut, you’d be hard-pressed to find more seasonal donut flair in Ohio than Holtman’s!

What orchards serve apple cider donuts in Ohio?

Ahh, the apple cider donut, another seasonal treat that’s not to be missed! There are some amazing apple cider mills and orchards in Ohio; and, as a result, a very robust list of places to find apple cider donuts in Ohio! Some of our go-to spots for ah-mazing apple cider donuts in Ohio include Haus Orchard and Cider Mill, MacQueen’s Apple Barn and Cider Mill, Beckwith Orchards, Hirsch Fruit Farm, Laurelville Fruit Farm, and Lynd’s Fruit Farm. Oh, and guess what? Lindsey’s Bakery in Circleville, Ohio, serves up incredible apple cider donuts, too!