Long Island is home to many bakeries, and many of them specialize in pie. You can eat some of the very best pie that you’ve ever had in your life in Nassau and Suffolk Counties, if you know where to go. If you’re looking to take a tasty road trip that you’ll never forget, then check out this fun and fantastic adventure to Long Island’s most mouth-watering pie shops. You can order the same type of pie at every stop and compare and contrast them all, or you can try a different kind of pie at each shop you visit. The possibilities are endless and this is a road trip you’ll likely want to do more than just once.
Read on to learn about Long Island’s best pie shops. Then, hop in your car with a big and eager appetite and get started right away!
The driving portion of this road trip will take a little over two hours from the first pie shop to the last. Don’t forget to add in time to browse, order, and eat the pies you choose, but it’s possible to make it to all seven pie shops in one day if you start early and move along quickly. Good luck!
Christy Articola/Google Maps
- Hallock’s Cider Mill; Laurel
Jenn/Google Local Hallock’s Cider Mill on the North Fork is a great place to start. This pie shop is known for its mini-pies so buy one to enjoy now, and choose a different one to bring home and eat later. Hallock’s Cider Mill, 1960 Main Rd, Laurel, NY 11948, USA
- Briermere Farms; Riverhead
Juliana Vetter/Google Local Briermere Farms’ pies consistently appear at the top of every list of best pies on Long Island. These pies are made from scratch on-site, and most of the fruit used in the pies is grown right in the fields outside. Briermere Farms, 4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901, USA
- Alpine Pastry Shop; Smithtown
Management/Google Local Alpine Pastry Shop is family owned and operated and offers a wide variety of excellent pastries. This road trip is in search of pies and this spot’s pies are spectacular, but that doesn’t mean you can’t buy and try other things too! Alpine Pastry Shop, 59 NY-111, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
- Hometown Bakeshop; Centerport
Management/Facebook Hometown Bakeshop in Centerport offers both sweet and savory baked goods and it’s a great place to stop for lunch if, for some odd reason, you need a break from pie. However, be sure to get one of this spot’s incredible pies for dessert. Hometown Bake Shop, 2 Little Neck Rd, Centerport, NY 11721, USA
- Kerber’s Farm; Huntington
Management/Facebook Kerber’s Farm has been serving Long Island since 1941! In addition to pie, Kerber’s also offers cooking lessons for all ages, a summer camp program, and accommodations if you want to stay at the farm. If you fall in love with Kerber’s pies, you can also have them shipped to your friends… or yourself. Kerber’s Farm, 309 W Pulaski Rd, Huntington, NY 11743, USA
- Jericho Cider Mill; Muttontown
Management/Facebook This shop is even older than Kerber’s Farm; it existed as far back as the early 1800s. However, Jericho Cider Mill became famous for its pies after it started selling them in 1968. The pies Jericho Cider Mill sells today are still made using the original family recipe. Jericho Cider Mill, 213 Jericho Oyster Bay Rd, Muttontown, NY 11753, USA
- Youngs Farm; Old Brookville
Dan B./Google Local Youngs Farm is also quite old; it was founded in 1893. Today, it’s a certified organic farm run by the fourth and fifth generation of the same family. Youngs offers great produce and even better pies, and it’s a great place to enjoy your seventh pie of the day. Youngs Farm, 91 Hegemans Ln, Old Brookville, NY 11545, USA
Are you full of pie yet? After visiting these seven incredible pie shops, you should be, but hopefully you brought home some pie to enjoy later on and tomorrow, too. If you’re like most people, there’s no such thing as too much pie, and there’s nothing wrong with doing this whole pie road trip all over again in the opposite direction! Have fun and hooray for pie!
Christy Articola/Google Maps
Jenn/Google Local
Hallock’s Cider Mill on the North Fork is a great place to start. This pie shop is known for its mini-pies so buy one to enjoy now, and choose a different one to bring home and eat later.
Hallock’s Cider Mill, 1960 Main Rd, Laurel, NY 11948, USA
Juliana Vetter/Google Local
Briermere Farms’ pies consistently appear at the top of every list of best pies on Long Island. These pies are made from scratch on-site, and most of the fruit used in the pies is grown right in the fields outside.
Briermere Farms, 4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901, USA
Management/Google Local
Alpine Pastry Shop is family owned and operated and offers a wide variety of excellent pastries. This road trip is in search of pies and this spot’s pies are spectacular, but that doesn’t mean you can’t buy and try other things too!
Alpine Pastry Shop, 59 NY-111, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
Management/Facebook
Hometown Bakeshop in Centerport offers both sweet and savory baked goods and it’s a great place to stop for lunch if, for some odd reason, you need a break from pie. However, be sure to get one of this spot’s incredible pies for dessert.
Hometown Bake Shop, 2 Little Neck Rd, Centerport, NY 11721, USA
Kerber’s Farm has been serving Long Island since 1941! In addition to pie, Kerber’s also offers cooking lessons for all ages, a summer camp program, and accommodations if you want to stay at the farm. If you fall in love with Kerber’s pies, you can also have them shipped to your friends… or yourself.
Kerber’s Farm, 309 W Pulaski Rd, Huntington, NY 11743, USA
This shop is even older than Kerber’s Farm; it existed as far back as the early 1800s. However, Jericho Cider Mill became famous for its pies after it started selling them in 1968. The pies Jericho Cider Mill sells today are still made using the original family recipe.
Jericho Cider Mill, 213 Jericho Oyster Bay Rd, Muttontown, NY 11753, USA
Dan B./Google Local
Youngs Farm is also quite old; it was founded in 1893. Today, it’s a certified organic farm run by the fourth and fifth generation of the same family. Youngs offers great produce and even better pies, and it’s a great place to enjoy your seventh pie of the day.
Youngs Farm, 91 Hegemans Ln, Old Brookville, NY 11545, USA
Looking for another Long Island road trip to try? How about this? The Lighthouse Road Trip On The New York Coast That’s Dreamily Beautiful
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
