What’s your favorite way to eat pumpkin pie? By cutting a slice as soon as it’s come out of the oven? Topped with plenty of fluffy whipped cream? Or, alongside a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream? Pumpkin pie just might be the most popular dessert of autumn. And, even if you don’t have time to make pumpkin pie, you’ll have plenty of opportunities to indulge in the delicious dessert. Here are six places to get some of the very best pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh.
- The Pie Place
Facebook/The Pie Place
Facebook/The Pie Place Dig into a generous slice of pumpkin pie from The Pie Place in South Hills. And, if you like pumpkin, you might want to try the pumpkin brownies, pumpkin cheesecake, and pumpkin snickerdoodles. Of course, the quaint pie shop also sells an assortment of pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes, and brownies.
The Pie Place is located at 1219, 1775 N. Highland Rd., Pittsburgh, PA, 15241. The Pie Place, 1775 N Highland Rd #1219, Pittsburgh, PA 15241, USA
- Oakmont Bakery
Facebook/Oakmont Bakery
Facebook/Oakmont Bakery Autumn’s all about the pumpkin at Oakmont Bakery. Indulge in one of the popular bakery’s rich pumpkin pies. And, stock up on other pumpkin favorites - gobs, cheesecake, bread, logs, muffins, and scones (to name just a few). Don’t forget to try the pumpkin spice cookies and the pumpkin glazed donuts, too.
Oakmont Bakery is located at 531 Allegheny Ave., Oakmont, PA, 15139. Oakmont Bakery, 1 Sweet St, Oakmont, PA 15139, USA
- Soergel Orchards
Facebook/Soergel Orchards
Facebook/Soergel Orchards Spend a few hours at Soergel Orchards, which also features a fall harvest/Halloween festival and a pumpkin patch each year. Pick your own pumpkins, and treat yourself to fresh-pressed apple cider. Then, stop in the bakery for a 10-inch pumpkin pie. (Pumpkin pies are available seasonally.) Other popular pies include apple, blueberry, and coconut cream.
Soergel Orchards is located at 2573 Brandt School Rd., Wexford, PA, 15090. Soergel Orchards, 2573 Brandt School Rd, Wexford, PA 15090, USA
- Prantl’s Bakery
Trip Advisor/management
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery Prantl’s Bakery may be known for its famous burnt almond torte. But, it also makes a delicious pumpkin pie. Pick up an eight-inch pumpkin pie. And, check out the other pie flavors, such as blueberry, caramel apple nut, and peach. Of course, Prantl’s Bakery, with three locations in Pittsburgh, also sells donuts, cookies, tortes, and cakes.
Prantl’s Bakery is located at 5525 Walnut St., Pittsburgh, PA, 15232. Prantl’s Bakery, 5525 Walnut St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, USA
- Gluuteny Bakery
Trip Advisor/Blanche F.
Trip Advisor/management Gluten free? You can still enjoy a delicious, home-made pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh! Gluuteny Bakery boasts a full line-up of delicious dairy-free and gluten-free goodies. Choose a traditional pumpkin pie. Or, order a mini pumpkin pie. Then, check out other popular pumpkin treats, including cupcakes, gobs, roll slice, and tarts. Whatever you order, you can’t go wrong at this award-winning Pittsburgh bakery.
Gluuteny Bakery is located at 1923 Murray Ave., Pittsburgh, PA, 15217. Gluuteny Bakery, 1923 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217, USA
- Pastries A-La-Carte
Trip Advisor/vladsuperman2
Facebook/Pastries A-La-Carte Autumn means the return of pumpkin pie at Pastries A-La-Carte. And, this quaint Pittsburgh bakery makes fresh traditional homemade pumpkin pies and gluten-free pumpkin pies. Browse the large selection of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and cheesecake.
Pastries A-La-Carte is located at 81 Clairton Blvd., Pittsburgh, PA, 15236. Pastries A-La-Carte, 81 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236, USA
Let’s add to this list of places to get the best pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh! Where’s your favorite place to get one of these delightful seasonal pies in Pittsburgh? Join the conversation in the comments below. And, while pumpkin pie may be the most popular dessert during autumn, apple cider and donuts come a close second. Here are some of the best cider mills in Pittsburgh you can visit for your apple cider donut fix.
Facebook/The Pie Place
Dig into a generous slice of pumpkin pie from The Pie Place in South Hills. And, if you like pumpkin, you might want to try the pumpkin brownies, pumpkin cheesecake, and pumpkin snickerdoodles. Of course, the quaint pie shop also sells an assortment of pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes, and brownies.
The Pie Place is located at 1219, 1775 N. Highland Rd., Pittsburgh, PA, 15241.
The Pie Place, 1775 N Highland Rd #1219, Pittsburgh, PA 15241, USA
Facebook/Oakmont Bakery
Autumn’s all about the pumpkin at Oakmont Bakery. Indulge in one of the popular bakery’s rich pumpkin pies. And, stock up on other pumpkin favorites - gobs, cheesecake, bread, logs, muffins, and scones (to name just a few). Don’t forget to try the pumpkin spice cookies and the pumpkin glazed donuts, too.
Oakmont Bakery is located at 531 Allegheny Ave., Oakmont, PA, 15139.
Oakmont Bakery, 1 Sweet St, Oakmont, PA 15139, USA
Facebook/Soergel Orchards
Spend a few hours at Soergel Orchards, which also features a fall harvest/Halloween festival and a pumpkin patch each year. Pick your own pumpkins, and treat yourself to fresh-pressed apple cider. Then, stop in the bakery for a 10-inch pumpkin pie. (Pumpkin pies are available seasonally.) Other popular pies include apple, blueberry, and coconut cream.
Soergel Orchards is located at 2573 Brandt School Rd., Wexford, PA, 15090.
Soergel Orchards, 2573 Brandt School Rd, Wexford, PA 15090, USA
Trip Advisor/management
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery
Prantl’s Bakery may be known for its famous burnt almond torte. But, it also makes a delicious pumpkin pie. Pick up an eight-inch pumpkin pie. And, check out the other pie flavors, such as blueberry, caramel apple nut, and peach. Of course, Prantl’s Bakery, with three locations in Pittsburgh, also sells donuts, cookies, tortes, and cakes.
Prantl’s Bakery is located at 5525 Walnut St., Pittsburgh, PA, 15232.
Prantl’s Bakery, 5525 Walnut St, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, USA
Trip Advisor/Blanche F.
Gluten free? You can still enjoy a delicious, home-made pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh! Gluuteny Bakery boasts a full line-up of delicious dairy-free and gluten-free goodies. Choose a traditional pumpkin pie. Or, order a mini pumpkin pie. Then, check out other popular pumpkin treats, including cupcakes, gobs, roll slice, and tarts. Whatever you order, you can’t go wrong at this award-winning Pittsburgh bakery.
Gluuteny Bakery is located at 1923 Murray Ave., Pittsburgh, PA, 15217.
Gluuteny Bakery, 1923 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217, USA
Trip Advisor/vladsuperman2
Facebook/Pastries A-La-Carte
Autumn means the return of pumpkin pie at Pastries A-La-Carte. And, this quaint Pittsburgh bakery makes fresh traditional homemade pumpkin pies and gluten-free pumpkin pies. Browse the large selection of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and cheesecake.
Pastries A-La-Carte is located at 81 Clairton Blvd., Pittsburgh, PA, 15236.
Pastries A-La-Carte, 81 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236, USA
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
The OIYS Visitor Center
best pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh August 19, 2022 Sarah M. Where can I find the best apple cider donuts in Pittsburgh? While there are numerous farms, apple orchards, and cider mills in and around Pittsburgh, we can never get enough of the goodies from Soergel Orchards. Sink your teeth into scrumptious Amish donuts then wash them down with freshly-pressed apple cider from the on-site mill – there truly is nothing that quite compares to their fresh cider. Oh, and the cinnamon rolls from this Pittsburgh spot? Out-of-this-world good. And you can pre-order them, too! A seasonal spot we simply adore is Trax Farms. We’re not alone, either; since 1964, this farm has been delighting generations of Pittsburgh families. The sprawling farm, which also hosts an annual fall festival, also features an apple cider press, and some of the very best seasonal baked goodies around. Finally, Freedom Farms Donut Shop specializes in the very best and freshest donuts in Pittsburgh. A bit of a hidden gem; they offer everything from maple-infused French toast donuts and pancake donuts to delicious spiced bear claws and nutty cinnamon rolls. Looking for more spots for your year-round donut fix in Pittsburgh? Take the Pittsburgh Donut Trail for the most delightful delicious day trip ever!
The OIYS Visitor Center
best pumpkin pie in Pittsburgh
August 19, 2022
Sarah M.
Where can I find the best apple cider donuts in Pittsburgh? While there are numerous farms, apple orchards, and cider mills in and around Pittsburgh, we can never get enough of the goodies from Soergel Orchards. Sink your teeth into scrumptious Amish donuts then wash them down with freshly-pressed apple cider from the on-site mill – there truly is nothing that quite compares to their fresh cider. Oh, and the cinnamon rolls from this Pittsburgh spot? Out-of-this-world good. And you can pre-order them, too! A seasonal spot we simply adore is Trax Farms. We’re not alone, either; since 1964, this farm has been delighting generations of Pittsburgh families. The sprawling farm, which also hosts an annual fall festival, also features an apple cider press, and some of the very best seasonal baked goodies around. Finally, Freedom Farms Donut Shop specializes in the very best and freshest donuts in Pittsburgh. A bit of a hidden gem; they offer everything from maple-infused French toast donuts and pancake donuts to delicious spiced bear claws and nutty cinnamon rolls. Looking for more spots for your year-round donut fix in Pittsburgh? Take the Pittsburgh Donut Trail for the most delightful delicious day trip ever!
The OIYS Visitor Center
The OIYS Visitor Center
While there are numerous farms, apple orchards, and cider mills in and around Pittsburgh, we can never get enough of the goodies from Soergel Orchards. Sink your teeth into scrumptious Amish donuts then wash them down with freshly-pressed apple cider from the on-site mill – there truly is nothing that quite compares to their fresh cider. Oh, and the cinnamon rolls from this Pittsburgh spot? Out-of-this-world good. And you can pre-order them, too!
A seasonal spot we simply adore is Trax Farms. We’re not alone, either; since 1964, this farm has been delighting generations of Pittsburgh families. The sprawling farm, which also hosts an annual fall festival, also features an apple cider press, and some of the very best seasonal baked goodies around.
Finally, Freedom Farms Donut Shop specializes in the very best and freshest donuts in Pittsburgh. A bit of a hidden gem; they offer everything from maple-infused French toast donuts and pancake donuts to delicious spiced bear claws and nutty cinnamon rolls.
Looking for more spots for your year-round donut fix in Pittsburgh? Take the Pittsburgh Donut Trail for the most delightful delicious day trip ever!
