Can you believe it’s nearly Halloween already? In honor of the approaching spooky season, there are many scary and haunted attractions popping up all across the Hoosier state. But sometimes, the real haunted legends are the best ones. If you love learning more about haunted Indiana, you’ll want to hear more about this allegedly haunted cave. Have you ever heard of the Milltown Indiana murders? Well… now you will.
Milltown, Indiana is a small town of approximately 800 residents, located in Harrison and Crawford Counties.
Chris Flook/Wikimedia This little town is located along the Blue River, a popular destination for summertime canoeing. However, this small town is also at the heart of a widely debated legend.
This little town is rumored to be the home of a haunted cave system, which was once a limestone quarry.
Ronald Branson/Flickr
This cave system is located near the Blue River and is believed to be the site of murders from the rumored Devil’s Mountain Cult.
Paul/Flickr The existence of this cult in Indiana is widely debated, but according to legend, the first killing took place on Halloween night in 1969.
The cave system is rumored to have been the cult’s hideout and is now dubbed by many as Devil’s Mountain.
Paul/Flickr While the murders reported seem to be real, there is no proof that a cult was to blame - but the rumors still remain.
While you shouldn’t visit the cave (it’s technically illegal and can earn you a ticket), it can be viewed from a distance.
Cave Country Canoes/Facebook What, are you scared? Go check it out! We dare you.
Have you ever heard about this haunted cave in Indiana? Which haunted places in Indiana fascinate you the most? Tell us your thoughts in the comments!
Chris Flook/Wikimedia
This little town is located along the Blue River, a popular destination for summertime canoeing. However, this small town is also at the heart of a widely debated legend.
Ronald Branson/Flickr
Paul/Flickr
The existence of this cult in Indiana is widely debated, but according to legend, the first killing took place on Halloween night in 1969.
While the murders reported seem to be real, there is no proof that a cult was to blame - but the rumors still remain.
Cave Country Canoes/Facebook
What, are you scared? Go check it out! We dare you.
For more haunted places, check out this list of creepy things to do in Indiana.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: Milltown, IN, USA
The OIYS Visitor Center
Milltown Indiana Murders August 24, 2022 Tori Jane Where is Devil’s Mountain, Indiana? Devil’s Mountain – or what is known as Devil’s Mountain – is actually a stone quarry located in Milltown, Indiana. It’s been the source of myth and rumor for many years, primarily on the internet. Some folks claim it’s one of the most haunted places in Indiana. Others claim it’s a made-up story from a blog online with nothing to back it up. One thing is for sure, though: it’s still one of the creepiest places in Indiana! What was the Devil’s Mountain cult? The Devil’s Mountain Cult was (supposedly) a shoot-off sect from Anton LaVey’s Church of Satan in the 1970s. Allegedly they performed numerous sacrificial murders over the years, and Devil’s Mountain was the spot they chose to do it all. Chances are, the Devil’s Mountain Cult never actually existed; more than likely it’s nothing more than an urban legend. However, the old stories have certainly made Devil’s Mountain one of the spookiest places in Indiana, and to this day, teenagers especially enjoy visiting the area just to see what it’s all about. There are no records of homicides in this area, nor is there any record of the Devil’s Mountain Cult actually existing… but it sure is a fun scary campfire story! What are some notoriously haunted places in Indiana? Indiana, like anywhere else, definitely has its ghosts. There just so happens to be lots of haunted places in Indiana, like one of its most beautiful state parks! They say Potato Creek State Park is haunted, and the cries of lost souls are audible in the night. Another notoriously haunted spot in Indiana is the infamous Whispers Estate, where the spirits allegedly can get quite aggressive with guests and researchers (so much so that sometimes a waiver is required to come check it out). Like we said, there are plentiful haunted places in Indiana… you just need to know where to look!
The OIYS Visitor Center
Milltown Indiana Murders
August 24, 2022
Tori Jane
Where is Devil’s Mountain, Indiana? Devil’s Mountain – or what is known as Devil’s Mountain – is actually a stone quarry located in Milltown, Indiana. It’s been the source of myth and rumor for many years, primarily on the internet. Some folks claim it’s one of the most haunted places in Indiana. Others claim it’s a made-up story from a blog online with nothing to back it up. One thing is for sure, though: it’s still one of the creepiest places in Indiana! What was the Devil’s Mountain cult? The Devil’s Mountain Cult was (supposedly) a shoot-off sect from Anton LaVey’s Church of Satan in the 1970s. Allegedly they performed numerous sacrificial murders over the years, and Devil’s Mountain was the spot they chose to do it all. Chances are, the Devil’s Mountain Cult never actually existed; more than likely it’s nothing more than an urban legend. However, the old stories have certainly made Devil’s Mountain one of the spookiest places in Indiana, and to this day, teenagers especially enjoy visiting the area just to see what it’s all about. There are no records of homicides in this area, nor is there any record of the Devil’s Mountain Cult actually existing… but it sure is a fun scary campfire story! What are some notoriously haunted places in Indiana? Indiana, like anywhere else, definitely has its ghosts. There just so happens to be lots of haunted places in Indiana, like one of its most beautiful state parks! They say Potato Creek State Park is haunted, and the cries of lost souls are audible in the night. Another notoriously haunted spot in Indiana is the infamous Whispers Estate, where the spirits allegedly can get quite aggressive with guests and researchers (so much so that sometimes a waiver is required to come check it out). Like we said, there are plentiful haunted places in Indiana… you just need to know where to look!
The OIYS Visitor Center
The OIYS Visitor Center
Devil’s Mountain – or what is known as Devil’s Mountain – is actually a stone quarry located in Milltown, Indiana. It’s been the source of myth and rumor for many years, primarily on the internet. Some folks claim it’s one of the most haunted places in Indiana. Others claim it’s a made-up story from a blog online with nothing to back it up. One thing is for sure, though: it’s still one of the creepiest places in Indiana!
What was the Devil’s Mountain cult?
The Devil’s Mountain Cult was (supposedly) a shoot-off sect from Anton LaVey’s Church of Satan in the 1970s. Allegedly they performed numerous sacrificial murders over the years, and Devil’s Mountain was the spot they chose to do it all. Chances are, the Devil’s Mountain Cult never actually existed; more than likely it’s nothing more than an urban legend. However, the old stories have certainly made Devil’s Mountain one of the spookiest places in Indiana, and to this day, teenagers especially enjoy visiting the area just to see what it’s all about. There are no records of homicides in this area, nor is there any record of the Devil’s Mountain Cult actually existing… but it sure is a fun scary campfire story!
What are some notoriously haunted places in Indiana?
Indiana, like anywhere else, definitely has its ghosts. There just so happens to be lots of haunted places in Indiana, like one of its most beautiful state parks! They say Potato Creek State Park is haunted, and the cries of lost souls are audible in the night. Another notoriously haunted spot in Indiana is the infamous Whispers Estate, where the spirits allegedly can get quite aggressive with guests and researchers (so much so that sometimes a waiver is required to come check it out). Like we said, there are plentiful haunted places in Indiana… you just need to know where to look!
